Skip to Content Top

What can I do if my insurance company drops me because of my roof?

|

1. Contact Your Insurance Company

In most states, insurers must give advance written notice — often 30–60 days for any cancellations or non-renewals.

Find out:

  • The exact reason (age? damage? underwriting guidelines?)
  • Your final coverage date
  • Whether they require full replacement or just proof of condition

2. Gather Documentation 

Pull together the following information:

  • Current roof installation date
  • Contractor invoice / documentation (if you have it)
  • Photos of current condition
  • Any inspection reports

If the roof is older (often 15–20+ years for asphalt shingles), many carriers won’t insure it — even if there are no current issues with the roof.

3. Contact a Trusted Roofing Company

Ask them to inspect the roof to determine: 

  • Current condition of the roof
  • If there are any vulnerable areas that could lead to problems
  • If they can estimate the age of the roof (if you are not sure)
  • If they can estimate the amount of life left in the roof

4. Decide: Repair, Replace, or Shop Around

Option A: Repair of Replace the Roof

This is often the most straight forward solution. Many insurers:

  • Will bind coverage once a contract is signed
  • Or require completion before binding

If replacing:

  • Use a licensed, trusted contractor
  • Keep invoice + warranty documentation
  • Get a roof certification from the contractor.  This can be provided to insurers to verify the date the roof was replaced.

Option B: Shop for New Insurance

Work with:

  • An independent broker (not a captive agent)
  • Someone who can quote multiple carriers

Carriers more flexible with older roofs may offer:

  • Actual Cash Value (ACV) roof coverage instead of Replacement Cost
  • Higher deductibles

4. Do NOT Let Coverage Lapse

A lapse can:

  • Make future insurance more expensive
  • Trigger mortgage issues
  • Force lender-placed insurance (very expensive)

If necessary, bind temporary coverage while you resolve the roof issue.

At Mighty Dog Roofing, we offer free roof inspections and we can help you with your roof related insurance problems. 

So, if you live in any of these areas:

  • Arlington Heights
  • Barrington
  • Cary
  • Deerfield
  • Fox River Grove
  • Highland Park
  • Lake Forest
  • Lake Zurich
  • Libertyville
  • Lincolnshire
  • Mundelein
  • Vernon Hills
  • Palatine 
  • Buffalo Grove
  • Algonquin
  • Carpentersville
  • Dundee

Please reach out to Mighty Dog Roofing at (847) 801-0373 for your free roof inspection.